Wanting to write ruins my read…

I don’t think I’ve honestly sat back and just enjoyed a book or short story ever since I made a conscious decision to want to be a published writer. I scrutinize and study every sentence, every paragraph, every comma, period, colon and parenthesis. When I stumble onto prose that astonishes me I rush to write it down in my notebook. I’m fully aware of plot and any possible developments that may or may not occur, so much so that I often accurately predict the outcome before I’ve read it.

There’s this gamer doing Black Ops videos on his thought process while he’s playing the game. See 2 guys. 1 left. Other right. Right guy can’t see me yet. Left guy is priority. Etcetera. That sort of thing. It’s kind of like what’s happening in my head when I read, except the thoughts in my head are not that short and precise but long and, quite possibly, over-analyzing.

I’m reading Eric Swett’s 100-Day Challenge (you should too), I get to Day 033 and this sentence:

““Would you like me to send in some refreshment?”  Her smile was pleasant with just a hint of arrogance.  She reveled in her immunity.”

And I’m like, whoa! She reveled in her immunity. How freaking powerful is that sentence? I mean, OK the word reveled by itself is a really strong word but look at how much character expose Eric jams into 3 short sentences. Look at how the previous 2 sentences lead up to the punch of the third.

A few days ago I was reading Sonia G MedeirosChange is in the Air and that whoa thing happens to me just 6 short sentences in:

“Dr. Marius pats Grandma. “You can’t rush biology.”
“His brothers changed younger than this. His little sister!”
Bet they heard that in the waiting room.”

Bet they heard that in the waiting room. Once again, one short simple sentence that says so much about the character uttering it. Then I spend the rest of the read marveling at how short and quick the structure is. How it reminds me of Howl. Then she slap shots a plot twist at me in the end. I go whoa, again.

Then there is this paragraph from Brent Weeks’ Night Angel trilogy:

“It was a place to inspire fear. Carved from black fireglass, a platform dominated the room. Nine chairs sat on the platform. A tenth chair sat above them like a throne. There was only a bare floor facing the chairs. Those the nine interviewed would stand.”

It was a place to inspire fear. Those the nine interviewed would stand. Take out those two sentences and you have nothing more than quick blase description of a room. A bland grouping of words that might not be missed if they where omitted and changed. But with those two sentences you have an ebb and flow of information, like a gentle wave that flows across the ocean and crashes down unexpectedly on your sand castle.

I especially love it when an author describes something so simply and yet so precisely the image pops into my head with ease as Dean Koontz does in his novel The Darkest Evening of the Year:

“In the salt-pale moonlight, an older middle-class neighborhood of one-story ranch houses seemed to effloresce out of the darkness.”

I’ve always felt my ability to describe surroundings in a way that does not feel stiff and contrived is a weak area of my writing. Take out the phrase seemed to effloresce out of the darkness and all you have left is a rather stiff description of some rural neighborhood. A few pages later Koontz turns up his talent for description and places his attention on a violent alchohoic:

“Carl Brockman turned his gaze on Brian. In those eyes shone not the mindless aggression of a man made stupid by drink , but instead the malevolent glee of a chained brute who had been liberated by it.”

…but instead the malevolent glee of a chained brute who had been liberated by it. How much more do we know about Carl Brockman because of this simple and elegant sentence? And here’s the kicker, Koontz doesn’t tell us this information he shows us.

Sometimes I think I could just pack up and shelve this dream of mine for good just so I could sit back, relax and truly enjoy a tale again.

About these ads

About Aj b33m3R

Just this guy.

Posted on May 23, 2011, in Productive Pondering, Writing and tagged , , , , , , , . Bookmark the permalink. 11 Comments.

  1. Wow. Heady company you have put me in. I don’t think this smile on my face will go away tonight. Thank you!

  2. I’m completely with you. Since I started writing, especially since I turned to YA, I can’t read anything and just enjoy. I rip apart the prose, over analyzing my own work while I do so. Are my sentences too complex? Am I describing the scene too much? My current WIP is a dystopian, so now my questions are: Is it too dry? But is it cold enough? yada, yada, yada. Great post.

  3. I have to agree with Eric about the perma-grin. :D I love that last example from Koontz especially. I also agree about having a hard time turning off the writer/editor when I’m reading. It’s like the old joke about the gynogologist.

    Chuck Wendig can really turn a phrase too. I read his anthology, Irregular Creatures and barely breathed through the whole thing…especially the Cat Bird one.

    • It was your sentence that made me think about this blog post idea last week, then I worked on some other things and forgot about it. Then I was catching up on Eric’s stuff and I recalled the idea and worked on it first thing.

  4. Those were great excerpts; they really showcase how to say more with less, and how to reveal character and situation without going into over-description. I agree with you; it seems the more you know about doing something, the more it ruins doing that for the sheer enjoyment. When I was doing undergrad my favorite thing to say was “I used to love reading, then I became an English major.” And now, teaching a fantasy lit class, I have a lot of students who have told me they analyze conventions and cliches in stories and movies without even meaning to.

    When it comes to gaming I find I’m rather susceptible to this as well. I tend to analyze story and character in games; if I don’t find the story or characters gripping or interesting I usually don’t much enjoy the game.

    All that to say, nice post that hit the proverbial nail.

  5. Wow, you’ve crushed my dream. Kidding, I was actually inspired.

    Fortunately I can still enjoy reading, even though I have become so focused on my writing. My problem has been that I now choose writing over reading for entertainment. I have quite a backlog of books that I want to read, but that is just going to have to wait.

    • Don’t worry dude, I don’t read as much as I should anymore either. It’s better to be more focused on your writing anyway. I think that’s great.

      Everything that pours out of me lately feels like shit, it’s a mental swing thing I guess. Been focused more on getting fit. 1-2 hours in the gym near everyday…

      Keep writing bro.

What's on your mind?

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

Follow

Get every new post delivered to your Inbox.

Join 115 other followers

%d bloggers like this: